Opinion / Li Xing
Freedom to blog is not license to slander
By Li Xing (China Daily)
Updated: 2007-04-12 07:11
Tim O'Reilly, whom the Chinese media call the "Internet heavyweight",
issued a proposed code of conduct on Sunday that asks bloggers to be
responsible for what they post on their blogs and refrain from attacking
others.
Suggesting that people should avoid posting anonymous comments, the code
was proposed after a well-known American blogger, Kathy Sierra, found
death threats posted on her blog last week, according to The New York
Times.
O'Reilly's proposal, which www.sina.com.cn has translated into Chinese
and posted in its science section, has drawn netizens' comments.
Some fear that the code would infringe on their freedom of expression and
their choice of whether or not to remain anonymous. Most support the idea
of making the web a civil place, not a battleground for harassment and
slander.
The debate will surely go on, but I believe such a code is necessary in
China, especially to avoid the spread of verbal violence on the Internet.
We Chinese should be familiar with what havoc verbal violence can wreck
on society.
When my friend recalled the early days of the "cultural revolution"
(1966-76) he asked me how I'd feel when I, as a teenager, went through my
home alley whose walls were plastered with posters screaming out
slanderous words against my father.
And when most of my neighbors shied away from me and pointed at me behind
my back, linking me with the condemned on the posters.
In those days, many people became targets for slander in their public
work as well as private life in the name of "rooting out capitalist
roaders", "anti-revolutionaries", "traitors" or "Western spies".
Those accusations naturally aroused anger, frustration, despair, guilt,
or all of these emotions.
When we came out of those chaotic years, the posters were made
unconstitutional and many of us vowed never to pick up the practice again.
However, the malignancy of the posters was so strong that its poisonous
effect is still being felt today in the age of the Internet.
In anonymity, bloggers and passers-by of BBS (Bulletin Board System)
sometimes gather to lash out at some popular film or music stars, using
all the derogatory labels they can think of.
Film star Zhang Ziyi recently has fallen victim to such attacks after the
media revealed that she posed nearly nude for an advertisement in Japan.
At other times, some netizens join hands battering people who commit a
wrong - such as a young woman who killed a stray cat in the street. They
use the violent lingo that was heard and read during the "cultural
revolution" years.
Some people may argue that a code of conduct not only deprives netizens
of their freedom of expression but also discourages criticism, which
society needs for healthy development.
Indeed, criticism is like doses of bitter medicine to help treat the ills
and wrongs in society or offer advice for better creative arts and other
works.
But viciousness, slander, and disrespect for people's individual choices
and private lives are not criticism. They are poisons that harm the
freedom of individuals and social harmony, whether they appear on the
Internet or in society.
E-mail: lixing@chinadaily.com.cn
(China Daily 04/12/2007 page10)
Hot Talks
� China Got Train Technology From Foreigners
� China is in urgent need of aircraft carriers
� Rematches, returns on tap in NBA playoffs
� Why AP chooses to report Cho's sister?
� Virginia Tech Shooting
Most Commented/Read Stories in 48 Hours
Learn mandarin
